1 star rating! von Garrincha | Philosophie Cartoon

Cartoons » Neue Cartoons

1 star rating!

#147284 / 5613 mal angesehen

von Garrincha
am 18. October 2011

18
Applause

Favorit

Melden

strike one!

Philosophie

rate

Kommentare (21)

Kommentar hinzufügen Seite 1 2 3

Member

@yavou:
agreed.

Garrincha, am 21. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

I wouldn't care so much about one one star rating.
There's always someone who gives you one. U just have to live with audience's taste and can't force your own upon them. Also we don't have that many trolls on toonpool. I only know of one.

Yavou, am 21. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

@Yavou:
True.
But if that's the case, comments help also.
I have had colleagues and readers alike pointing at things they don't like or don't understand in some of my cartoons, and many, many times they have been absolutely right about it.
And it's appreciated.
So why not use the comments option to get your point across if needed?
I don't recall any 1 star rater offering any explanation about the rating.
Not that they are supposed or expected to do it, but the fact that they post their lone star and leave doesn't help us understanding what their rationale was.

Garrincha, am 21. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

One Star can also be a hint to get better. Especially for beginners. Usually our friends and family like everything we do. So toonpool ratings offer some truth. Also I believe the audience looks at the cartoons in a completely differnt way than artists do. To have seperate ratings one by artists and one by non-artists would be interesting.

Yavou, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

@tricomix:
thanks!
btw, we all wish we could do better with this or that cartoon every once in a while, so you are not alone.
after we see them posted or printed we wish we could draw them different.
so it better be a good thing!

Garrincha, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

@67:
that's the spirit!
thanks for sharing.
click!
:)

Garrincha, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

@dad o matic:
very good choice.
i guess all cartoonists work to show their toons and expect some criticism, not to bother with ratings.
yet the system is not perfect and somehow empowers trolls.
thanks for your words.

Garrincha, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

Hi Gustavo,
Thank you for this topic. I've noticed that many awarded for tactical reasons, a bad evaluation.
I award five stars or not. With no star, I don`t like the cartoon without making him ill!

We face a competition! But awarding of stars with a comment whether one or five is more honest!

Incidentally, I find my own often Cartoons shit!

I wish me to deal with each other respectfully and honestly would expire.
Finally, we shed a lot of heart blood, sweat when creating our images.

Five stars for your picture and this topic *****

Tricomix, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

Isn't it one star which is the best rating?
I know it from school. 1 is the best grade.
But on the other hand, 5 is more than 1 !?!
And what if the 3 is the best, because it is in the middle of all and 5 and 1 is off target?
And what if all the stars are just a mirage!?
Oh, it's so confusing ;-)

I trust the Favorit button - and my mouse.

Voegelcartoons, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0

Member

Just my opinion,I don't focus on ratings,i just love to draw, the only competition is myself.We are passion driven, and I am honored to be amungst like minded artists.

DaD O Matic, am 20. October 2011 Beitrag melden antworten applause 0